Phantom Menace | EP 1 | The Confidante
Sep 24, 2026 · 47m
Summary
Host Andrea Gunning introduces Season 6 of Betrayal, focusing on the story of Carl Bryant, a Kenosha, Wisconsin man who navigates his identity as a bisexual, overweight individual. The episode details Carl’s close friendship with Paul Augustine and his turbulent romantic relationship with Adam Mejia, which is plagued by Adam’s severe alcoholism and eventual imprisonment for a DUI. After their breakup, Carl confides in Paul about his fears regarding Adam’s release from prison, unaware that Paul is secretly plotting a sinister revenge against him. The narrative sets the stage for a shocking b…
Topics discussed
Sponsors and introduction
The trusted friend and the security camera audio
Host introduction and episode title
Meeting Carl Bryant and his background
Carl's youth and activism in Kenosha
Carl's struggle with sexuality and coming out
Coming out to family and the newspaper
Sponsor breaks and Carl's body image struggles
Meeting Paul on dating apps and first date
Developing friendship with Paul and moving to Madison
Meeting Adam and the initial connection
Becoming a couple and Adam's drinking issues
Sponsor breaks and the toll of the relationship
Carl's bariatric surgery and moving in together
Escalating conflict and Adam's aggression
A brief vacation and getting a dog
The breakup and Adam's threatening departure
Adam's car accident and arrest
Adam's prison calls and Paul's return
Credits and final sponsor reads
Listen ad-free on Castria