Why Does the Internet Hate Cognitive Behavioral Therapy? With Dr. Ellen Hendricksen
Sep 21, 2026 · 1h 33m
More Self-Improvement podcasts
Summary
Forrest Hanson and Dr. Ellen Hendrickson explore the history, strengths, and criticisms of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). They trace its evolution from behaviorism to modern third-wave approaches like DBT and ACT, emphasizing its structured, evidence-based nature. The episode addresses common social media critiques, such as CBT feeling invalidating or overly reductive, while highlighting its effectiveness for anxiety and depression.
Topics discussed
Introduction to CBT and the show's 7th anniversary
Guest intro: Dr. Ellen Hendriksen and her books
What happens in a typical CBT session
The role of homework and learning theory in CBT
The CBT model: thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
CBT vs. other modalities: warmth and fit
The three waves of CBT: an overview
Wave 1: Behaviorism and the reaction to psychoanalysis
Behaviorist tenets and the gift of exposure
Classical conditioning: Pavlov and Little Albert
Ethical issues in early conditioning experiments
Mary Cover Jones and deconditioning fear
The pendulum swing from Freud to behaviorism
Wave 2: The Cognitive Revolution and Aaron Beck
Beck's work on depression and cognitive distortions
Replicability and the scientific basis of CBT
Teachability of CBT and its limitations
Challenges in CBT practice: exposure and client withdrawal
Sponsor segment: Shopify
Sponsor segment: MasterClass
Sponsor segment: Quince
Wave 3: Shift from change to acceptance
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) and Marsha Linehan
DBT skills and the dialectical approach
Self-criticism within the CBT field
Acceptance frameworks and patient experience
Comparing waves: handling social anxiety
Cognitive and ACT approaches to fear
Fit issues: CBT and insurance mandates
Insurance limitations and CBT's reputation
The problem of brief therapy sessions
CBT worksheets and the feeling of data entry
When CBT is not a good fit: cognitive spectrum
Validating catastrophizing thoughts
Trauma and the limits of present-focused CBT
Re-scripting trauma and the risk of gaslighting
Dealing with intellectualizing clients
Personal anecdote: emotional avoidance and feedback
The need for supportive challenge in therapy
Unskillful CBT and the feeling of self-gaslighting
CBT is not positive thinking: clear glasses
Rupture and repair in the therapeutic relationship
Perfectionism: rules, performance, and worth
The suffering of high standards and achievement
Defining perfectionism: demanding more than required
Why lowering standards is not the intervention
The function of perfectionism: problem solving
Perfectionism, isolation, and the desire to belong
Working on hypercriticalness and over-identification
Exposure and self-compassion in perfectionism
Intermediate beliefs and core beliefs in perfectionism
Giving credit to the self vs. the work
Procrastination and anxiety management
Breaking tasks down to reduce resistance
Connecting with the future self to reduce procrastination
Fear of failure and the application process
Doing the task while feeling bad
Competence vs. connection: the mask of performance
Admiration vs. love and belonging
Internal beliefs about likability and value
Self-criticism as a hardwired group mechanism
Managing post-podcast self-criticism
The order of action and feeling: behavior first
Leading with behavior and the cave of bats
Where to find Dr. Hendriksen's work
CBT's internal evolution and self-critique
The scientific method and therapy approaches
Peeling back layers of assumptions in thoughts
Recap: history, ethics, and the cognitive revolution
Recap: CBT vs. sleeping pills and cognitive fit
Outro: fit, insurance, and bad experiences
Outro: brief therapy and lasting change
Outro: perfectionism, social anxiety, and safety behaviors
Closing remarks and Substack promotion
More from Being Well with Forrest Hanson and Dr. Rick Hanson
Listen ad-free on Castria