Being Well with Forrest Hanson and Dr. Rick Hanson Being Well with Forrest Hanson and Dr. Rick Hanson

Why Does the Internet Hate Cognitive Behavioral Therapy? With Dr. Ellen Hendricksen

Sep 21, 2026 · 1h 33m

Summary

Forrest Hanson and Dr. Ellen Hendrickson explore the history, strengths, and criticisms of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). They trace its evolution from behaviorism to modern third-wave approaches like DBT and ACT, emphasizing its structured, evidence-based nature. The episode addresses common social media critiques, such as CBT feeling invalidating or overly reductive, while highlighting its effectiveness for anxiety and depression.

Topics discussed

Introduction to CBT and the show's 7th anniversary Guest intro: Dr. Ellen Hendriksen and her books What happens in a typical CBT session The role of homework and learning theory in CBT The CBT model: thoughts, feelings, and behaviors CBT vs. other modalities: warmth and fit The three waves of CBT: an overview Wave 1: Behaviorism and the reaction to psychoanalysis Behaviorist tenets and the gift of exposure Classical conditioning: Pavlov and Little Albert Ethical issues in early conditioning experiments Mary Cover Jones and deconditioning fear The pendulum swing from Freud to behaviorism Wave 2: The Cognitive Revolution and Aaron Beck Beck's work on depression and cognitive distortions Replicability and the scientific basis of CBT Teachability of CBT and its limitations Challenges in CBT practice: exposure and client withdrawal Sponsor segment: Shopify Sponsor segment: MasterClass Sponsor segment: Quince Wave 3: Shift from change to acceptance Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) and Marsha Linehan DBT skills and the dialectical approach Self-criticism within the CBT field Acceptance frameworks and patient experience Comparing waves: handling social anxiety Cognitive and ACT approaches to fear Fit issues: CBT and insurance mandates Insurance limitations and CBT's reputation The problem of brief therapy sessions CBT worksheets and the feeling of data entry When CBT is not a good fit: cognitive spectrum Validating catastrophizing thoughts Trauma and the limits of present-focused CBT Re-scripting trauma and the risk of gaslighting Dealing with intellectualizing clients Personal anecdote: emotional avoidance and feedback The need for supportive challenge in therapy Unskillful CBT and the feeling of self-gaslighting CBT is not positive thinking: clear glasses Rupture and repair in the therapeutic relationship Perfectionism: rules, performance, and worth The suffering of high standards and achievement Defining perfectionism: demanding more than required Why lowering standards is not the intervention The function of perfectionism: problem solving Perfectionism, isolation, and the desire to belong Working on hypercriticalness and over-identification Exposure and self-compassion in perfectionism Intermediate beliefs and core beliefs in perfectionism Giving credit to the self vs. the work Procrastination and anxiety management Breaking tasks down to reduce resistance Connecting with the future self to reduce procrastination Fear of failure and the application process Doing the task while feeling bad Competence vs. connection: the mask of performance Admiration vs. love and belonging Internal beliefs about likability and value Self-criticism as a hardwired group mechanism Managing post-podcast self-criticism The order of action and feeling: behavior first Leading with behavior and the cave of bats Where to find Dr. Hendriksen's work CBT's internal evolution and self-critique The scientific method and therapy approaches Peeling back layers of assumptions in thoughts Recap: history, ethics, and the cognitive revolution Recap: CBT vs. sleeping pills and cognitive fit Outro: fit, insurance, and bad experiences Outro: brief therapy and lasting change Outro: perfectionism, social anxiety, and safety behaviors Closing remarks and Substack promotion

More from Being Well with Forrest Hanson and Dr. Rick Hanson

Anhedonia: Why Nothing Feels Good Anymore, and How to Fix It
Nov 16, 2026
Reducing Emotional Reactivity and Finding Inner Peace with Yung Pueblo
Nov 9, 2026
How to Stop Feeling Self-Conscious: Escaping the Panopticon
Nov 2, 2026
How to Break Relationship Patterns: Resolving Conflict and Communicating Your Needs
Oct 26, 2026
How to Fix Insomnia: CBT-I with Dr. Ashley Mason
Oct 19, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria