Part One: Martin Niemöller, the author of 'First They Came', was a murderous fascist
Sep 29, 2026 · 59m
Summary
Host and guest Margaret Killjoy examine the life of German poet Martin Niemöller, challenging the common narrative that he was a passive, apolitical critic of the Nazis. They argue that Niemöller was actually a fervent nationalist and anti-Semite who enthusiastically supported the early Nazi regime before later becoming a prisoner of conscience. The episode traces his upbringing in a deeply patriarchal, militaristic Lutheran household and his obsession with the German Navy, illustrating how his personal biases shaped his infamous "First They Came" poem.
Topics discussed
Introduction and guest Margaret Killjoy
Debating H.P. Lovecraft's legacy
Analyzing Martin Niemöller's famous poem
The poem's origin and modern adaptations
Niemöller's actual anti-fascist history
Sponsor segments and transition
Niemöller's ancestral background in Germany
Martin Luther and the Lutheran faith
Luther's antisemitism and revolutionary impact
The Niemöller family and the name Martin
Father Heinrich's influence and paterfamilias role
Growing up in a hierarchical, church-dominated home
Early impressions and anti-semitic sects
Kaiser Wilhelm and the naval expansion
Sponsor segments and correction
Martin's childhood dream of joining the navy
Martin's personality and early education
Naval training and Kaiser Wilhelm's address
Early naval service and WWI outbreak
Sponsor segments and WWI blame list intro
Assigning blame for World War I
Martin's wartime actions and ethical gray areas
Sponsor segments and conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria