The Midnight Wraith
Nov 15, 2026 · 32m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode explores the legend of the "Midnight Wraith," a bizarre, wingless aerial creature reportedly terrorizing Crawfordsville, Indiana, in 1891. The narrative details eyewitness accounts from ice workers and a local reverend who described a massive, pale, worm-like entity with glowing eyes that circled the town while emitting mournful cries. The story examines various theories for the phenomenon, ranging from undiscovered species and dimensional travelers to mundane explanations like flocks of killdeer attracted by new electric streetlights or a cruel prank involving a suspended animal.
Topics discussed
Sponsored segment: Avocado Green Mattress
Introduction to mysterious aerial creatures and folklore
The Mothman legend and Silver Bridge collapse
Thunderbirds and Native American traditions
Hovering humanoid figures in Latin America
Theories for unexplained aerial sightings
Background on Crawfordsville, Indiana
Ice workers prepare for delivery in 1891
Witnesses feel sudden dread and look up
Sponsored segment: Shopify for Black Friday
Description of the worm-like creature
Creature circles barn and witnesses flee
Reverend Switzer witnesses the apparition
Switzer's wife sees the creature and it departs
Sponsored segment: Chime credit card
Local reaction and fading of the story
Charles Fort revives the story in 1931
Additional witness accounts from locals
Unique characteristics of the Midnight Wraith
Rational explanations and prank theories
Conclusion and teaser for Cable Line Monster
Sponsored segment: SimpliSafe home security
More from Bedtime Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria