PJ Harvey with Ann Powers, Part 2
May 26, 2022 · 3h 1m
Summary
In this second installment of the PJ Harvey series, host Yossi Salik and NPR critic Ann Powers analyze the 1995 album *To Bring You My Love*. They discuss the record’s shift toward a complex, collaborative sound featuring producers Flood and John Parish, as well as the archetypal themes of femininity, death, and spirituality. The conversation also explores Harvey’s relationship with Nick Cave, her exploration of blues influences, and her critical stance on contemporaries like Oasis.
Topics discussed
Introduction and the 'Bandsplain' concept
The tension of the Nick Cave and Polly Harvey friendship
The isolation and difficulty of recording 'Rid of Me'
Comparing 'Rid of Me' and 'To Bring You My Love'
Sponsor break and early alt-radio hits
Influences: Alice Walker and Southern Gothic myths
The impact of the UK trip-hop scene on her sound
Her artistic leap and personal life context
Speculation on abortion themes in 'White Chalk'
Archetypal struggles and feminine identity in her work
Recalling a legendary live performance at the Academy
The concept of 'wild creatures' and desire in rock
Analysis of the song 'Long Snake Moon'
Playing 'Long Snake Moon' and reading a critique
Her roots in the African diaspora and Black music
Her relationship to Black Britain and collaboration with Tricky
The lineage of rock music and its Black origins
The commercialization of blues and white appropriation
Her eclectic tastes: Take That and 50s R&B
The beauty of simplicity versus art school complexity
Her childhood as a horse jumper and 'going into the white'
The beginning of her collaboration with Nick Cave
The trouble of public myth-making and personal identity
The irresistible twinning of Harvey and Cave
The intensity and power dynamics of their relationship
Her interest in spoken word and slam poetry
Her correspondence with Captain Beefheart
The 90s context: Madonna, Hal Hartley, and 'Amateur'
The musical shift on 'To Bring You My Love'
Lyrical analysis and the 'peace' reference
The changing perception of side projects and collaborations
Her acting role in the film 'The Rapture'
Nostalgia for the trip-hop era: Tricky, Portishead
The production team for 'Stories from the City'
The drive and hooks in 'Stories from the City'
Muted vocals and the complexity of mourning
Spiritual parallels in their relationship
Catholic imagery and the film 'Household Saints'
J.D. Salinger references and themes of suicide
Nick Cave's thoughts on the album's sequencing
Her left turn to a more muted vocal style
Her public statements on the Nick Cave relationship
The meaning of 'Is This Desire Enough?'
Banter about being a music critic
Her later relationship with Viv Albertine
The pendulum swing in her musical style
The duet with Tom York on 'This Mess We're In'
Her indifference to critical counterpoint
The joy and directness of 'Good Fortune'
Escaping self-torture in 'Horses in My Dreams'
The tragedy of the 9/11 timing for her career
Her diverse collaborations, including Sparklehorse
Her place in the X scene lineage
The sexual nature of performance: Kiedis and Harvey
The Primus connection and Mark Lanegan
The Coachella experience and scene dynamics
Her preference for playing with male musicians
The 'ugly' and hard-to-listen-to nature of the record
The difficulty of categorizing PJ Harvey
The lack of a strong persona on this album
The humor in 'Who the Fuck'
The maturity of 'Don't Make My Wedding Dress'
The letter to her ex and her prose style
The band 'Her' and the dedication to Vincent Gallo
The spiritual conversation with Nick Cave through art
The gathering of songs and personal anecdotes
Her career as a continuous artistic evolution
The Mark Lanegan collaboration 'Hit the City'
Her collaboration with Marianne Faithful
The Mick Harvey 'pub and gym' joke
Her vocal timbre and range on this record
The intentional limitation of writing on piano
The 'cottagecore' and contained girlhood themes
The Janelle Monae comparison
Her songwriting process and spiritual channeling
The debate on whether lyrics are poetry
The 'handshake emoji' and taking art to new places
Re-evaluating the album after repeated listens
Creating a framework for many voices to inhabit
The Richard Thompson WWI letters project
The Andrew Marr show and the 'Four Lads' song
The use of effects pedals and male backing vocals
The Mercury Prize win for 'Let English Shake'
Turning outward to the world's troubles
The documentary journey to Kosovo and Afghanistan
The Brechtian alienation in her lyrics
The 'Sex and the City' pilot as a Brechtian example
The structure of her memoir and Dorset dialect
Her seductive, witchy power as a front person
The terror and beauty of her artistic inhabitation
Choosing 'Red Right Hand' as the closing song
The Peaky Blinders recognition and final thoughts
More from Bandsplain
Listen ad-free on Castria