PJ Harvey with Ann Powers, Part 1
May 19, 2022 · 3h 44m
Summary
In this episode of Bandsplain, host Yossi Salek and NPR music critic Ann Powers discuss the early life and career of PJ Harvey. They explore her rural upbringing in Dorset, her childhood gender identity struggles, and her musical influences, including blues and post-punk. The conversation also covers her time in the band Automatic Dlamini and the release of her debut single, "Dress."
Topics discussed
Introduction to Bandsplain and PJ Harvey episode
PJ Harvey's artistic themes: religion, mysticism, and art
Astrological profile and early family background
Early influences: classic rock, blues, and sculpture
Gender identity struggles and childhood interviews
Visual aesthetics and the 'arty' rock star persona
Career longevity and consistent artistic evolution
Parodying beauty and sexual allure in her work
Nick Cave influence and the 'Trent Reznor' debate
Captain Beefheart and Howlin' Wolf influences
Tomboy identity and dissonant rock preferences
Early bands: The Polkats and Bologna
Touring with other bands and bootleg recordings
U2 connection and the penny whistle as punk instrument
The 'PJ Harvey' name confusion and Blondie comparison
Context of women in indie rock in the early 90s
L7 influence and the 'Mad Max' aesthetic
First live performance and hostile audience reaction
Signing to 4AD and Ivo Watts-Russell
Analysis of 'Dress': layers of meaning and critique
The body, ugliness, and sexual vitality
Gender roles and who is allowed to perform
Underground film influences and blues tradition
Problematic content and artistic redemption
Repelling and attracting: the core of her appeal
Early swag and named influences: Waits and Cave
Style in the English rock press and volatile scene
John Peel sessions and BBC Radio 1 debut
Water symbolism and childhood by the river
Narrative structure and immersion in myth
Religious stories and Greek myths as inspiration
Mainstreaming of indie music and Citizen Dick
Bowie influence and return to theatricality
The album 'Dry': minimalist words and humor
Placement alongside Nirvana and Pixies
Analysis of 'Victory' and the mundane miracle
Female orgasm in music and Prince's 'When Doves Cry'
Sexuality, 'O Stella', and website biography edits
Bernini's St. Teresa and ecstasy imagery
NEA censorship and transgressive art
Patti Smith parallels and period blood art
Purification of rock and classic rock lineage
Confrontational sexuality and Patti Smith's twin
Doing their own thing and Patti Smith's legacy
Analysis of 'Sheila Hage': being huge and accused
Personal anecdotes and the broken gate
Daily life surrounded by ancient imagery
Period blood as art and public reaction
Feminism label and Melody Maker interview
Second wave feminism and redefining the term
Career consequences of associating with feminism
Personal views on using the word feminist
Inscrutability of gender and refusal of categories
Riot Grrrl as political and art movement
Critique of lazy feminist critiques
Marginalization of women and confronting the issue
Did being a woman make it easier? A debate
Pronouns, 1991 context, and surfacing issues
Body as canvas and visual art school background
Hyper-feminine drag and future career trajectory
Touring logistics and the Zoo TV Tour comparison
Self-possession, fear, and post-Dry struggles
Writing 'Rid of Me' and anticipating shock
Releasing demos and Flood as producer
Personal unhappiness and hiring Steve Albini
Influence of obscure aggressive bands
Steve Albini's ventriloquism book and singing style
Vengeful woman archetype and 'Boiled Bunny'
Intellectual processing vs. bodily presence
Demonization, witchcraft, and 'Meet the Monster'
Motion in music: desire, repulsion, and hunger
Steve Albini's unique microphone setup
Gay community co-optation and Nicki Minaj comparison
Tour documentary 'Reeling' and performance image
Biography, mental health, and public denial
Sex and pain: interpreting the lyrics
Seaside retreat and Russian folk music interest
Literary influences: Carmen Maria Machado and Angela Carter
Aching for connection and emotional resonance
Bob Dylan influence and taking on the canon
Courtney Love's critique and gender performance
Machismo, anger, and self-humiliation
Love sickness and sensual chaos in lyrics
Industrial music and BDSM imagery context
Early reviews: Entertainment Weekly and Albini's production
Male critics understanding women's experiences
Collaborations: Mark Lanegan and Greg Dulli
Rolling Stone interview with Liz Phair
Critique of 'no heart' and emotional depth
Songwriting role and band dynamics
Vocal comparisons: Chris Cornell and female voices
Revenge of women in rock and objectification
Album cover aesthetics and cellophane imagery
Canon of male songs and mental illness tropes
Visibility of pain and Prozac Nation parallels
Mystery in lyrics and gender ambiguity
Competition with the MBAC and sexual dynamics
Q Magazine profile and Bjork/Morrissey anecdote
More from Bandsplain
Listen ad-free on Castria