How Should the Siri App Be Graded?
Summary
John Voorhees and Federico Viticci discuss the iOS 27 beta, focusing heavily on their critical assessment of the new Siri app and Apple Intelligence. They argue that Siri’s AI capabilities lag significantly behind free alternatives like ChatGPT and Gemini, offering shallow, generic responses and poor tool integration. The hosts demonstrate Siri’s failures in handling complex file management and personal context searches, contrasting them with superior third-party AI workflows.
Topics discussed
Intro and podcast selection habits
iOS 26 release timeline and beta boredom
Siri AI limitations vs. ChatGPT and Gemini
Siri improvements and Finalist sponsor segment
The AI bubble: Apple vs. frontier models
Shallow responses and web search substitution
User adoption and Siri app popularity
Tool calling limits and Finder integration issues
Passable results syndrome and indexing quirks
Live demo: Siri searching messages and notes
Spotlight integration and app intent gaps
Inoreader sponsor segment
Golden Gate UI changes and Spotlight indexing
Demo: ChatGPT plugin searching iMessage history
Final verdict: Siri as a solid but dated chatbot
OpenAI's everything app concept and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria