Episode 38: Umdaar by Evil Hat
Summary
Analytic Dice Episode 38 reviews *Umdar: Planet of Swords* and the *Dark Eye* RPG. Hosts Gabe and Kevin discuss listener calls regarding board-game-to-RPG hybrids before detailing their Fate Core experience with *Umdar*. They analyze mechanics like aspects, fate points, and stress, praising the system's elegance while noting the setting's complexity and potential for complication fatigue.
Topics discussed
Intro: Episode 38, Umdar, and Dark Eye
Discussion on RPGs vs. Board Games (Warhammer Quest)
Listener Call: Max on Dark Eye and Descent
Max's feedback on Dark Eye mechanics and setting
Hosts' impressions of Dark Eye art and combat
Transition to Umdar: First-time Fate experience
Umdar Character Creation: Archetypes and Bioforms
Fate Core Mechanics: Dice, Skills, and Stunts
Invoking Aspects and Spending Fate Points
The Four Actions: Overcome, Create, Attack, Defend
Stress, Consequences, and GM Complications
Complexity Comparison: Fate vs. 2d20 and Champions
Pacing Issues: Action for Action's Sake vs. Momentum
Final Verdicts on Umdar and Fate System
Popcorn Initiative and Strategic Turn Order
Outro: Next Episode Preview and Sign-off
Listen ad-free on Castria