American Hysteria American Hysteria

Halloween Newspapers.com Dive pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall

Sep 21, 2026 · 1h 23m

Summary

Host Chelsea Weber-Smith and guest Sarah Marshall kick off a Halloween-themed series by playing a game where they search newspapers.com for obscure historical articles using specific keywords. They discuss an 1888 article detailing Mischief Night pranks, highlighting how girls were active participants in the chaos, and a 1976 piece where dentists discouraged candy in favor of fruit. The episode blends historical research with lighthearted banter about horror movies, seasonal traditions, and the cultural inversion of fear during the holiday.

Topics discussed

Introduction to the Halloween Newspapers.com special Hosts introduce themselves and explain the game rules Halloween plans, haunted houses, and bowling anecdotes Revealing keywords and discussing the 'Weber' doorbell coincidence Mischief Night history and an 1888 article on apple peeling Sponsor reads for Quince and AG1 Reading the 1888 Mischief Night article: corn, gates, and cabbages Discussion of an 1888 clam juice advertisement Sponsor reads for Quince and AG1 1970s article on Halloween treats: toothbrushes vs. candy Debate on horror movie preferences: Saw, Terrifier, and Midsommar The 'Grins' monster sticker campaign and its failure Sugar lobby influence on dental advice and trick-or-treating ethics Sponsor reads for Quince and AG1 1900 article: Quakers moving due to a Phantom Dog Fan fiction ideas and character time management in TV shows 1923 article: A man, a dog, and a missing ear Part 2 teaser, credits, and sign-off
Listen ad-free on Castria