A Trial by Podcast A Trial by Podcast

Ep. 124 | Carmen Tarleton: A Story of Resilience

Aug 4, 2026 · 1h 7m

Summary

Host Kelsey recounts the 2007 attack on nurse Carmen Tarleton by her estranged husband, Herb Rogers, who assaulted her with a bat and industrial lye. The episode details Carmen’s survival against odds, including 38 surgeries and a pioneering face transplant that restored partial sight. It covers Rogers’ 30-to-70-year sentence and death in prison, while highlighting Carmen’s resilience and the host’s advocacy for organ donation.

Topics discussed

Intro and sponsor message Host intro, moving update, and domestic violence resources Carmen Tarleton's background and relationship with Herb The attack: Herb's assault with a bat and lye The science of lye burns and immediate aftermath Emergency response, hospitalization, and initial injuries Recovery, legal proceedings, and Herb's sentencing Long-term rehabilitation and introduction to organ donation The importance of organ and tissue donation Carmen's life post-attack and decision for face transplant The first face transplant surgery and recovery Life with a new face and signs of rejection Second face transplant, donor meeting, and conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria