True Crime: Gary Simmons Jr
Summary
This episode covers the 1996 murder of Jeffrey Wolf in Mississippi, where Gary Simmons Jr. and Timothy Milano killed Wolf and dismembered his body with butcher knives. The narrative centers on Charlene Lezer, who survived being kidnapped, raped, and confined in a footlocker before escaping to become the key witness. The hosts discuss the investigation, Simmons' conviction for capital murder, and the 16-year appeal process that concluded with his execution in 2012.
Topics discussed
Intro and show announcements
Host banter and pregnancy anecdotes
Trigger warnings and case overview
Background: Jeffrey Wolf and the debt
The murder in Moss Point, Mississippi
Charlene Lezer's captivity and escape
Discussion on bystander safety in the 90s
Investigation and recovery of remains
Gary Simmons' cryptic VHS message
Tangential discussion on jury selection
Trial evidence and Charlene's testimony
Verdicts and sentencing
Appeals and the 16-year legal battle
Execution and the 29,000-calorie meal
Reflection on survivors and justice
Outro and mental health resources
Listen ad-free on Castria