5-4 5-4

250 Years of Bad Decisions Pt. 2: The Law Was Never Neutral [TEASER]

Oct 6, 2026 · 4m

Summary

Hosts Peter, Rhiannon, and Michael open this 5 to 4 episode with a humorous recap of Eric Schmidt’s congressional hearing, where he mistakenly accused Jack Smith of attending an Atlanta Hawks game instead of an Iowa Hawkeyes game. The group then transitions to their "250 Years of Bad Decisions" series, examining the history of the Supreme Court in honor of the nation’s 250th birthday. The main discussion focuses on the concept of judicial neutrality, arguing that right-wing actors have weaponized the perception of legal neutrality to obscure the court's fundamentally political nature.

Topics discussed

Intro: Supreme Court history series for 250th birthday Episode theme: Weaponizing judicial neutrality Host banter and Eric Schmidt hearing context Schmidt's accusation of collusion with Fani Willis The 'Hawks game' text message evidence Jack Smith's denial and the poster board reveal Correction: Iowa Hawkeyes vs. Atlanta Hawks Klobuchar's intervention and Schmidt's reaction Critique of the hearing's chaotic nature Series update and podcast thesis on law Patreon subscription pitch and benefits
Listen ad-free on Castria