The Two Faces of Todd Winkler
Oct 28, 2026 · 40m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the murder of Rachel Winkler by her husband, Todd Winkler, a former Air Force pilot and pharmaceutical executive. The narrative explores Todd's history of bizarre behavior, including the suspicious death of his first wife in a fiery crash, and his alleged manipulation of Rachel, who feared for her life before being stabbed to death.
Topics discussed
Introduction: The Operation Sidewipe insurance fraud scheme
Courtroom outburst and the murder of Rachel Winkler
Todd Winkler's background and Rachel's final warning
The stabbing incident and psychiatric defense claims
Life in Cameron Park and the Winkler family's arrival
Rachel's father's warnings and the rapid marriage
Raising the children and Rachel's memory in art
Marital struggles, financial issues, and the decision to divorce
The 911 call and Winkler's initial confession to police
James White, the affair, and Rachel's fear of Todd
Prosecutor dissects the self-defense claim and motive
Winkler's history of psychiatric episodes and faking illness
The previous wife's death and the staged accident scheme
The 1999 Georgia crash and the rescue by campers
Investigation of the 1999 crash and Catherine's autopsy
Trial opening and the prosecution's strategy
The courtroom outburst and Winkler's pattern of lies
The prosecution's account of the murder and cleanup
Winkler's testimony and chilling admissions on the stand
Defense expert testimony on dissociative and conversion disorders
Closing arguments: Self-defense vs. premeditated murder
Verdict of first-degree murder and sentencing
Aftermath: Family impact and ongoing quest for justice
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria