48 Hours 48 Hours

The Corn Rake Witness

Nov 9, 2026 · 41m

Summary

This episode investigates the wrongful conviction of Todd Mullis, who was sentenced for the murder of his wife, Amy, after she was found impaled by a corn rake on their Iowa farm. Todd's son, Tristan, recounts the traumatic event and alleges he was pressured to testify against his father, while new forensic experts argue that Amy's injuries resulted from an accidental fall rather than a deliberate attack.

Topics discussed

Cold open: The I-10 trucking incident Sponsor reads: Audible and Maurice's Tristan Mullis recounts finding his mother Trial testimony and the witness dilemma Todd Mullis's innocence campaign Tour of the Iowa farm and family history Reconstructing the morning of the incident The search for the pet carrier and discovery Amy Mullis's death and family grief Todd Mullis's murder trial begins Forensic analysis of the corn rake wounds Motive: Affair and domestic tension Todd's testimony and defense strategy Pressure on Tristan to testify Sponsor read: Jenny Bird jewelry Life in prison: Todd's eight years Timeline analysis: The water hose break Physical evidence of Todd's state Impact on the children and family dynamics Tristan's affidavit accusing family Family response to the accusations Defense attorney's controversial strategy New legal team: The Neshwatts Sponsor read: Chime banking New experts challenge the murder theory Medical evidence: Bruises and swelling The corn rake wound trajectory debate Biomechanics of the fall and struggle Self-inflicted injuries during removal Reconstructing Amy's final movements Coat evidence and autopsy photos Medical records and prior procedure Environmental hazards: Augers and path Conclusion: It was a farm accident Sponsor read: Rover pet care Sponsor read: Thumbtack services Legal strategy for a new trial Challenging the motive narrative Text messages and relationship dynamics Evaluating Amy's fear statements Expert testimony in the hearing Classification of manner of death Validity of expert opinions in 2019 Response to critical review of findings State's closing argument against relief Defense closing and Tristan's hope Judge Parrish denies the new trial Reasons for the judge's decision Family reaction to the denial Amy's brother defends the murder verdict Next steps: Appeal and continued fight Tristan's message to his father Sponsor read: Nissan Rogue

More from 48 Hours

The Last Traces of Christina Downer
Nov 20, 2026
Live to Tell: The Vendetta
Nov 18, 2026
The Shape of a Killer
Nov 18, 2026
Post Mortem | Murder at Mount Hood
Nov 17, 2026
Murder at Mount Hood
Nov 16, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria