Post Mortem | The Corn Rake Witness
Nov 10, 2026 · 27m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode features 48 Hours correspondent Erin Moriarty discussing the ongoing fight to overturn the murder conviction of Iowa farmer Todd Mullis, who was sentenced to life in prison for his wife’s death. The conversation highlights new forensic evidence suggesting the death was an accident, the first public testimony from their son Tristan, and the recent denial of a post-conviction relief hearing. Despite the judge’s ruling, Mullis’s family and legal team plan to appeal, continuing to challenge the original verdict based on biomechanical analysis and witness accounts.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Chime fee-free banking and credit card
Sponsor: The First Wife podcast and Audible
Introduction to the Todd Mullis case and guest Erin Moriarty
Recap of the 2018 incident and Tristan's discovery
Initial police theory and public reaction to the corn rake
Forensic evidence, motive, and the original trial conviction
How defense attorneys Dina and Daniel Neshwat got involved
Tristan Mullis clarifies his testimony and speaks out publicly
Farm tour: analyzing distances and barn layout for alibi
Analysis of the 911 call and rural emergency response times
Conditions in the red shed and proximity to the family home
Sponsors: SNHU and Rover
New expert testimony: Dr. Hammers and Dr. Nye's accident theory
Biomechanics: why swinging the rake is physically implausible
The missing coat evidence and original defense counsel's failure
Testimony from original attorney Gerald Firehelm at PCR hearing
Atmosphere of the hearing and arguments from both families
Judge's denial of post-conviction relief and final ruling
Future appeals, audience reaction, and case conclusion
Sponsor: Nissan Rogue
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria