Post Mortem | What the Cameras Saw
Oct 27, 2026 · 22m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode of 48 Hours investigates the 2022 murder of Savannah Tolbert in Huntsville, Alabama, whose husband David Tolbert was convicted of capital murder. The discussion covers the forensic evidence, including gunshot residue and Tesla Sentry Mode footage, that contradicted David’s initial claim of suicide. The hosts also explore the impact of the tragedy on Savannah’s daughter, Avery, and the complex relationships involving David’s affair with Chelsea Finch.
Topics discussed
Promo for Over My Dead Body: Operation Sideswipe
Audible and Culligan Purity advertisements
Introduction and discussion on video evidence
Savannah's death and initial scene investigation
Savannah's background, advocacy, and family life
Mental health struggles and pre-death behavior
Gunshot residue evidence and David's first interview
The affair with Chelsea Finch and potential motive
Valley Pools surveillance footage analysis
Chime banking advertisement
Maurice's clothing advertisement
Tesla Sentry Mode and missing video evidence
Medical examiner findings and homicide determination
Arrest, Chelsea's reaction, and breakup letter
Trial details, defense arguments, and verdict
Avery's life, resilience, and Huntsville space hub
Closing remarks and call to action
Nissan Rogue advertisement
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria