Post Mortem | The Detective and the Chewing Gum Sting
Oct 20, 2026 · 26m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode of Postmortem features host Anne-Marie Green and correspondent Peter Van Sant discussing the 48 Hours season premiere, "The Detective and the Chewing Gum Sting." They explore how cold case detective Susan Logothetti solved two decades-old murders by tricking serial predator Mitchell Gaff into providing DNA evidence via an undercover chewing gum taste test. The conversation covers Gaff’s violent history, his time in civil confinement, and his eventual guilty plea to the murders of Judy Weaver and Susan Vesey.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Squarespace and Thumbtack
Introduction to the season premiere story
The 1984 murder of Judy Weaver and prime suspect
Detective Logothetti takes over cold cases
DNA results identify Mitchell Gaff as suspect
Gaff's history: The 1979 assault on Jackie Brown
The Special Commitment Center and civil confinement
Journalist Tom Juneau's profile of Gaff's duality
Gaff's release and new identity as Sam Wise Price
Sponsor: Culligan Purity
The undercover chewing gum sting operation
Inside Gaff's home and collecting DNA samples
Arrest and Gaff's denial during interrogation
Solving the second cold case: Susan Vesey
Gaff's guilty plea and Detective Logothetti's role
Victim Jackie Brown's life after the attack
Closing remarks and call to action
Sponsor: Nissan Rogue
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria