The Pretender
Summary
This episode details the 2001 murders of Mary Jane Longo and her three children by their father, Christian Longo, who fled to Mexico assuming the identity of New York Times reporter Michael Finkel. After Finkel, recently fired for fabricating a story, connects with Longo in prison, they develop an unusual correspondence. Longo is convicted and sentenced to death, though his sentence was later commuted to life in prison, while Finkel explores the psychological dynamics of their relationship.
Topics discussed
Discovery of the Longo family murders in Oregon
Chris Longo flees to Mexico and impersonates Mike Finkel
Mike Finkel's career collapse and initial contact with Longo
The developing correspondence and friendship between Finkel and Longo
Investigation reveals Longo's history of fraud and deception
Longo's financial crimes and strained marriage to Mary Jane
The family's disappearance and Longo's new life in Cancun
Longo's arrest in Mexico and return to the US
Finkel's moral dilemma and Longo's trial preparation
The trial: Longo's partial confession and testimony
Verdict, death sentence, and Longo's shifting confessions
Aftermath: Commutation of sentence and lasting impact
Listen ad-free on Castria