48 Hours 48 Hours

Inside the Sentencing of the GIlgo Beach Serial Killer

Jun 19, 2026 · 34m

Summary

48 Hours correspondent Aaron Moriarty and legal analyst Caroline Polisi discuss the sentencing of Rex Heuerman, the Long Island serial killer. Heuerman pleaded guilty to seven murders, receiving consecutive life sentences without parole. The episode features emotional victim impact statements and details how investigators used DNA and cell records to identify the suspect after years of stalled progress.

Topics discussed

Introduction: Rex Heuerman's sentencing and guilty plea Case origins: The Gilgo Four and the cold investigation Breakthrough: Task force, DNA evidence, and arrest The killer's double life: Family man and hidden monster Legal strategy: Guilty plea and FBI cooperation The blueprint: Meticulous planning and jail behavior Victim impact statements: Families confront Heuerman Sentencing: Judge's emotional remarks and life sentence Conclusion: Comparisons to other killers and final thoughts

More from 48 Hours

The Last Traces of Christina Downer
Nov 20, 2026
Live to Tell: The Vendetta
Nov 18, 2026
The Shape of a Killer
Nov 18, 2026
Post Mortem | Murder at Mount Hood
Nov 17, 2026
Murder at Mount Hood
Nov 16, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria