Fatal Choice
Oct 21, 2026 · 37m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 2009 murder of Dr. Peter Franklin by his wife, Sandra, who claimed self-defense after he allegedly attacked her with a keychain knife. Investigators found no evidence of prior abuse or physical struggle, suggesting Sandra ambushed Peter in the laundry room to secure his $3 million in assets and a life insurance policy before their divorce. Despite defense arguments that Peter was the aggressor, the jury convicted Sandra of voluntary manslaughter, and she was sentenced to 15 years to life in prison.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Maurice's clothing and fit advice
Sponsor: Chime fee-free banking
The stabbing incident and initial police response
Peter Franklin's death and Sandra's arrest
Peter Franklin's life, career, and previous relationships
Sandra and Peter's courtship and marriage
Sponsor: Southern New Hampshire University
Sponsor: Squarespace website design
Financial disputes and drug investigation
Reconstruction of the fatal argument and stabbing
Forensic evidence and inconsistencies in the story
Investigation into motives and fabricated injuries
Trial begins and defense strategy
Sponsor: Heart Starts Pounding podcast
Trial testimony: Forensics and expert witnesses
Closing arguments and jury deliberation
Sponsor: Culligan water filtration
Verdict: Guilty of voluntary murder
Sentencing and Sandra's final statements
Aftermath: Auction of assets and Peter's burial
Sponsors: My Mom's Murder and Nissan Rogue
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria