The Case Against Enrico Forti
Nov 5, 2026 · 41m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 1998 murder of Dale Pike and the subsequent conviction of Italian windsurfer Enrico Forti, who has spent 20 years in prison despite a lack of forensic evidence linking him to the crime. Reporter Joe Tacopina explores the case's suspicious circumstances, including a botched police investigation and questionable forensic testimony, while interviewing Forti, his family, and the victim's brother.
Topics discussed
Sponsorships: Figs scrubs and Rover pet care
Introduction to the Dale Pike murder mystery
The Pike family and the Ibiza hotel deal
Crime scene analysis and staged evidence
Tony Pike's health and meeting Enrico Forti
Sponsorship: Chime banking
Promo: Over My Dead Body podcast
Forti's account of picking up Dale Pike
Police investigation and Forti's initial lies
Thomas Connaught: The con man suspect
Charges, alibis, and the accomplice theory
The sand evidence and forensic flaws
Trial testimony and pathologist errors
Jury deliberation and guilty verdict
Sponsorship: Southern New Hampshire University
Promos: Unsolved Mysteries and Squarespace
Forti's life in Italy and legal campaign
New witness and interview with Connaught
Brad Pike visits the crime scene
Sponsorships: Jenny Bird and Nissan Rogue
Internal police doubts and closed doors
Forti's family, forgiveness, and transfer to Italy
Sponsorship: Rhode Island tourism
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria