Dangerous Games
Oct 22, 2026 · 38m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This 48 Hours episode investigates the 2012 murder of 19-year-old Elizabeth Marriott in New Hampshire. It details how her boyfriend, Seth Mazzalia, strangled and raped her after she rejected his sexual advances, while his partner, Catherine McDonough, helped dispose of the body in the ocean. The narrative follows the investigation, Mazzalia's arrest, and the subsequent trial where McDonough testified against him as part of a plea deal. The story concludes with Mazzalia's conviction for first-degree murder and rape, and his sentencing to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Topics discussed
Sponsored segments: Squarespace and Wayfair
Trial highlights: The murder of Lizzie Marriott
Lizzie's life and background at UNH
The disappearance and initial police investigation
Introducing Kat McDonough and Seth Mazzalia
Seth's dark side and the couple's online activities
Police questioning and Seth's initial confession
Sponsored segments: Maurices and Culligan
Search for the body and Seth's arrest
Testimony from Seth's ex-girlfriend Catherine
Kat's initial statement: The accident theory
Family reaction and Kat's arrest for hindering investigation
Trial begins: Prosecution's case and Kat's testimony
Reconstructing the night: The sexual encounter
The murder, rape, and aftermath testimony
Sponsored segments: Chime and Heart Starts Pounding
Disposal of the body and evidence
Defense strategy and physical evidence analysis
Sponsored segments: California Closets and Xero Shoes
Closing arguments and the guilty verdict
Sentencing and the family's memorial
Sponsored segments: Nissan and Sierra
More from 48 Hours
Listen ad-free on Castria